Ask locals where to get the best pizza around Brunswick and the Golden Isles and you’ll get two things very quickly:
Strong opinions
Multiple people shouting the same few names
A recent community discussion proved something interesting — our “community” actually has a surprisingly serious pizza scene.
Here’s where locals say you should go when the pizza craving hits.
Arte Pizza (Downtown Brunswick)
If there was a clear winner in the conversation, Arte Pizza downtown might take the crown.
Multiple locals chimed in simply saying:
“Arte Pizza downtown.”
“Arte’s is the best. Nobody else comes close.”
Others mentioned that Arte’s is their go-to Brunswick pizza spot, especially when they want classic brick-oven style pies.
For many locals, Arte has become the downtown pizza benchmark.
🍕 CJ’s Pizza
Another spot that generated a lot of mentions was CJ’s Pizza.
Fans praised it enthusiastically:
“CJ’s hands down the best.”
“CJs!!!”
CJ’s is particularly known for deep-dish pizza, which one commenter quickly pointed out when the topic came up.
That said, the discussion also showed how passionate pizza fans can be — a few locals felt the quality had slipped recently, proving that pizza debates can get serious around here.
Sal’s Neighborhood Pizzeria
Another strong contender mentioned several times was Sal’s.
Locals praised not only the pizza but also the broader menu:
“Sal's and they have lots of good food too.”
For many people in the area, Sal’s has been a longtime dependable pizza spot.
Broomelli Boys Pizzeria
Several locals also recommended Broomelli Boys, with one commenter saying:
“Broomelli gets my vote.”
Another local suggested that Broomelli might even edge out Sal’s, showing just how competitive the pizza rankings can get.
Brogen’s North
A few locals pointed to Brogen’s North as another solid option, particularly on the north side of town.
🍕 Other Mentions from Locals
A few additional places popped up in the conversation as well:
Fox’s Pizza (Downtown)
Pizza Inn
Savannah Pizza Company
Friendly Express (yes, really)
Harris Teeter’s Supreme Pizza (a surprisingly popular budget pick)
Because sometimes the best pizza is simply the one closest when the craving hits.
The Local Verdict
Based on the comments, the Golden Isles pizza hierarchy looks something like this:
Top mentions
• Arte Pizza
• CJ’s Pizza
• Sal’s
Also strong local favorites
• Broomelli Boys
• Brogen’s North
One thing is certain: pizza debates in Brunswick are alive and well.
